Erin Moriarty Kelley Fliehler Danika Yarosh Caroline Found Helen Hunt Kathy Bresnahan William Hurt Ernie Found Nesta Cooper Lizzie Ackerman Jason Gray-Stanford Scott Sanders Natalie Sharp Mack Tiera Skovbye Brie Lillian Doucet-Roche Taylor Burkely Duffield Alex Cassandra Bagnell Twin Tower #2 Rebecca Staab Bethany Steve Richmond Gregg Found Garry Chalk Principal Shaw Makena Lei Carnahan Ruby Dee Jay Jackson Jim Candus Churchill Pie Shop Owner Ava Grace Cooper Little Kelley Bailey Skodje Little Line Jan Bos Finals Announcer Michael Meneer News Reporter J.C. Williams West High Ref Carolyn Adair Mother (uncredited)