Amy Forsyth Natalie Reign Edwards Brooke Bex Taylor-Klaus Taylor Christian James Quinn Roby Attal Gavin Matt Mercurio Asher Courtney Dietz Britney Cynthea Mercado Jodi Stephen Conroy The Other Markus Silbiger Bored Carny Kid Michael Tourek Security Guard Tony Todd The Barker Aaron Gillespie Stagehand Elle Graham Little Girl Kimberly Battista Demonic Nun (uncredited) Shaun McMillan Hellfest Halloween Park Goer (uncredited) Milton Saul Hell Fest Halloween Park Goer / Event Staff (uncredited) Quandae Stewart Halloween Park Goer / Booth Worker (uncredited) Brooke Jaye Taylor Cop (uncredited) Benjamin Weaver Hellfest Halloween Park Goer (uncredited)