Michael Shannon Gary Noesner Giovanni Ribisi Dan Cogdell Keean Johnson Vernon Howell Abbey Lee Carol Howe Alex Breaux Timothy McVeigh John Hoogenakker Clive Doyle Kali Rocha Ruth Riddle Michael Luwoye Livingstone Fagan Michael Cassidy Bill Johnston Sasheer Zamata Angie Graham David Costabile Judge Walter Smith J. Smith-Cameron Lois Roden Gary Cole Gordon Novel Shea Whigham Mitch Decker John Leguizamo Jacob Vazquez Steven Williams Alan Sanborn Seamus Dever Andy the German Mark Speno Doug Tinker Mimi Fletcher Jury Forewoman Lori Rae